This playlist is the best way to learn about the The Grievance Studies Affair’ and track the story as it unfolds — https://bit.ly/2zkBKBn
This is first video revealing the behind-the-scenes story of how a trio of concerned left-wing academics (James Lindsay, Peter Boghossian and Helen Pluckrose) published seven intentionally absurd papers in leading scholarly journals in what has become known as ‘The Grievance Studies Affair’.
This series is associated with a feature-length documentary I’m working on. My plan is to play around with some of the footage I gather and upload it here to generate an audience and have a creative outlet while I learn about the complicated subject matter.
My usual sources of film funding are blocked off to me because of the sensitive subject matter and the slow approach I’m taking. If you think what I’m doing is valuable and you’re in a position to help, you can support the project here — https://www.patreon.com/mikenayna
For anyone uncomfortable with Patreon, one-off transfers can be done here
— https://paypal.me/mikenayna
Read the full papers and project fact sheet: http://bit.ly/2OsWnnH
The Wall Street Journal’s take: https://www.wsj.com/articles/fake-news-comes-to-academia-1538520950
Washington Post: https://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/outlook/2018/10/04/paper-that-would-never-have-gotten-past-peer-review-criticizes-academy-film
New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/06/opinion/grievance-studies-hoax.html
Mother Jones: https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2018/10/cultural-studies-is-the-target-of-another-hoax-and-this-one-stings/
The Times: https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/journals-publish-hoaxers-absurd-gender-studies-q7f60l7v6
The Australian: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/higher-education/a-degree-of-shame-as-academics-fall-for-grievance-studies-hoax/news-story/f5dd6380dac3cd42406ed21a689203f8
Buzzfeed: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/virginiahughes/grievance-studies-sokal-hoax
Ben Shapiro May Never Stop LOLing At This: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PwFmrI5QQFI
Featuring:
James Lindsay (@ConceptualJames)
Peter Boghossian (@peterboghossian)
Helen Pluckrose (@HPluckrose)
Mike Nayna (@MikeNayna)
NOTE: This video is cleared for fair use on the provision this source video is embedded or a prominent hyperlink to this video features in your content.
I ask that you please respect all of the individuals that appear in my videos and keep your thoughts and feelings to the video in the comment thread.
#GrievanceStudies #TheyDontSpeakForMe #PeterBoghossian #JamesLindsay #HelenPluckrose #MikeNayna #SokalSquared #GrievanceStudiesAffair #GenderStudies #Feminism #Intersectionality #JoeRogan
Смотреть в источнике
43 комментария
You can see why the Women's March became so cozy with racists, antisemites and installed islamofacists like Linda Sarsour as their leadership. Trust me folks, 2019 is the year the MeToo movement dies and it will be by their own hand. Hilarious!!!
This is the most amazing thing I've seen in- almost forever.
good luck with this guys. Seriously. I graduated in 1983 from U of Cal in "area studies". I've lived and traveled in my area of 'expertise' for over 30 years, and nothing I learned in uni applied to what I have experienced. I could talk Marxist theory all day and night but could never see it in action on the ground any where that I lived. People were not behaving according to the 'theory'. So where did all the data come from in all these books and academic journals I read for two years?? I confronted one of my former professors with this info and he ignored me and returned to grading papers. I also seriously considered suing the U of Cal to get my parents' money back, but was told it was impossible to prove fraud.
So like I said: good luck.
I couldn't handle the rigors of Gender Studies, so I changed my major to Theoretical Physics — and it's a breeze. Maxwell's equations are far easier to understand than neo-post modern sexual intersectionalities. Unfortunately, I won't ever be able to make the big bucks you get as a professional gender studiesist.
Those two slobs are academics?
Grievance Studies?…. Dafuq? Never heard of that
Just WONDERFUL 🙂
Many are calling what they did ‘trolling’, but what they did is clearly an act of scholarship.
I don't know if this is funny or terrifying
Ironically this whole thing is academically dishonest; I've watched a couple videos about these guys and somehow they manage to never mention the Sokal affair. Like they came up with this idea themselves…. smh . Google it!
Why is this not more widely noted? This is scary!
excellent work. il looks that gender is a "science" for idiots and by idiots.
The people have exposed the system for what is wrong with the entire academy!
I would love to thank this team of brave academics for their innovative & impactful project. I hope all scholars & students who encounter it will emerge wiser & frankly more self-aware.
The one point I’d make is that you felt the need to wave the flag “We are left wing.” You felt the need to signal that you’re part of the in crowd & have permission to speak critically. Just having graduate degrees & jobs at universities & a portfolio is not enough credential to be taken seriously. The implication of singling out your left wing opinions is that the exact same work from an independent or right winger would not be considered acceptable.
I’m concerned you may be reinforcing the politicized culture of the intellectual sphere while criticizing it.
Writers like Victor Davis Hanson, Heather MacDonald, & Roger Kimball have been sounding the alarm bell about decay within academia for many years. They don’t have the left wing label. Does the label make the work?
Thank you!
just wow
The left excels at producing highly educated morons.
Fantastic!
I would be interested in actually immersing myself in some of their theoretical papers so that I better understand their arguments and presumably their flaws. Any recommendations as to their “best” literature and where to find it? Thanks
no se si estar feliz o asustado
Well done
What's with all of the down votes? This is EXACTLY what's wrong with our society now. I can only imagine that the thumbs down are from those who are so steeped in corrupt social reconstruction "education" that they can't recognize truth when it's point blank proven to them. I, for one, will not send my children to a college that focuses more on the bogus social justice nonsense than teaching critical thinking and truth in their academics studies. College students are coming out of these institutes with no more maturity and real life education after 4 + years of college than a 15 year old in high school. A minimum of 7 years of schooling and they are not progressing! This is why!
just dont blame all of it on (((them)))
And climate science has become about as corrupt as grievance studies.
http://sealevel.info/climategate.html
Thank you for trying to bring dignity and integrity back into the sciences! You guys are a shining light.
"If this doesn't acheive anything, it would actually frighten me…"
Isn't the results of this more scary than your potentially tarnished reputation?
Thank you so much for doing this! Now that people are seeing how rotten their industry of lies truly is, we can finally start changing things for the better again. The war against freedom of ideas is coming to an end at last!
I don't understand what is going on here.
The Mein Kampf one is called "Our Struggle Is My Struggle: Solidarity Feminism as an Intersectional Reply to Neoliberal and Choice Feminism." I found it and the link is below:
https://www.scribd.com/document/390022198/Our-Struggle-Is-My-Struggle-Solidarity-Feminism-as-an-Intersectional-Reply-to-Neoliberal-and-Choice-Feminism
I love this, I absolutely love this.
"You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you cannot fool all of the people all of the time." -Abe
The legacy of the dysfunctional left end gender and social justice crazies.
Regarding your screenshot at 1:28 from Informa PLC’s website, what the hell made-up word is “performativity” supposed to mean?
This is the most amazing and incredible thing. I could never have imagined something like this could happen.
Next step a support group for doggy victims of rape . Will there be workshops for those of us who would like to be doggy rape victim counselors or do we just give them a treat and say "good dog" ?
Hey have y’all connected with Johnathan Haidt yet?????
love what you are doing
Holy fuck…
Finally my Cultural Anthropology class makes sense. It’s not me…. it’s them. Thank GOD
https://xkcd.com/451/
You guys are freaking hero’s!
this is as scary as it is funny….
How easy it is to expose the feminist agenda of hate.
Brave, and legitimate scientist exposing the liberal lfeminist agenda. Well done.